The
Barcelona Process, Israel’s Perspective
By
Silvan Shalom, Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs
(IMFA) A
decade ago, the Barcelona Declaration stated that members of
the process are “convinced that the general objective
of turning the Mediterranean basin into an area of dialogue,
exchange and cooperation guaranteeing peace, stability and
prosperity requires a strengthening of democracy and respect
for human rights, sustainable and balanced economic and social
development, measures to combat poverty and promotion of greater
understanding between cultures, which are all essential aspects
of partnership”.
Peace, stability
and prosperity for the Mediterranean basin are the declaration’s
main goals. Israel, in the spirit of the Barcelona Declaration,
saw the Barcelona process then as it does today, as an important
and a correct means to fulfilling Israel’s long-standing
dream. Our dream is to live in peace, understanding, tolerance
and cooperation with all our neighbors. The road towards this
goal is stated in the same declaration: dialogue, exchange
and cooperation.
Israel shares
the new ideas and initiatives put forth and accepted unanimously
at the Luxemburg Euro-Med Conference in May 2005, promoting
political and economic reform, human rights and education,
through concrete and measurable actions. Nevertheless, we feel
it is necessary to return to the essential ideas that are the
driving force and the raison d’etre of the Barcelona
process.
In our view,
the Barcelona process framework is the ideal framework for
breaking old stereotypes, misguided myths and erroneous beliefs
between nations. In other words, it can serve to prepare the
ground and the hearts for peace and cooperation.
Israel has
recently completed its disengagement from the Gaza region as
well as from four villages in northern Samaria. Disengagement
was meant to be the turning point necessary to create a change
in the stalled political process between Israel and the Palestinians.
The momentum created by this move should be used in order to
create a constituency for peace in our region. It should serve
to empower the moderate forces and further isolate the extremists
bent on continuing the cycle of violence.
The Barcelona
process can and should serve as the catalyst for as many projects
as possible in those areas in which we can identify interests
common to us all. Beyond the clear and immediate benefits of
such projects, they can also serve as excellent confidence-building
measures (CBM’s). History has shown us more than once
the ability of CBM’s in promoting mutual understanding,
tolerance and collaboration. Furthermore, the benefits of these
projects are supposed to serve as tangible proof of the “fruits
of peace” and to increase public interest in reaching
the goals set forth by the Barcelona Declaration.
In the last
decade, Israel has tried, through its governmental and non-governmental
representatives, to show the highest level of involvement in
any possible cooperation. We are not starting from zero - Israel’s
participation in regional projects dates back to the first
days of the Barcelona process.
Within the
political-security basket Israel is involved very actively
in the Development of a Euro-Mediterranean System of Mitigation,
Prevention and Management of Natural and Man-made Disasters
project, which recently went into the implementation phase.
Within the regional economic cooperation basket, in the framework
of strengthening commercial relations with Jordan and the EU,
we signed a Pan-European Accumulation agreement.
Israel, the
Palestinian Authority and the EU signed an agreement to open
a Joint Energy Office and a Joint Transportation Office in
order to establish common projects with EU backing.
Israel’s
Minister of Communications participated in the first Euro-Med
conference of Communications Ministers.
Within the
social-cultural basket, projects included: the Euro-Med Youth
Exchange Program, the Medea program, eight projects in the
framework of the Euro-Med Heritage programs. Israelis were
also involved in education and training programs as well as
in the EUMedis program involving information society.
The highlight
of this basket, in our view, was the establishment of the “Anna
Lind Foundation” for inter-cultural dialogue. Israel
was among the first supporters of this project and among the
first to pledge financial backing for the foundation.
Now we must
look to the future.
Those who
claim that the main obstacle before advancing in the Barcelona
process is the stalemate in the Middle East peace process,
represent an attitude that prevents the parties to the Barcelona
process from fulfilling its full potential. The Euromesco report
of February 2005 states the following:
“…political
dialogue and CBM’s are designed to facilitate efforts
at conflict resolution. If CBM’s are held hostage to
conflict resolution, the logic of the measures goes to waste.
Thus, the conditionality that has been accepted in the EMP
is the EXACT OPPOSITE of what these measures are designed to
achieve.”
It matters
not what the main objectives of the members of the Barcelona
process are: peace and prosperity, democratization, economic
reforms, human rights, empowerment of civil society or other
goals. In any case, we must focus on maximizing the potential
inherent in the Barcelona process in order to support the advancement
of the peace process. The way to achieve this goal is through
as many CBM’s as possible, as long as they are varied
and available to all.
In recent
months, we can again feel the winds of cautious optimism blowing
throughout our region. We are hopeful that maybe this time
all sides will join us and show a real will to reach the peace,
stability and prosperity that have eluded us for too long,
that are still close and yet out of reach.
We hereby
call on all the members of the Barcelona process: For peace,
let us work together in order to create a social, cultural
and economic infrastructure for the immediate welfare and long-term
fulfillment of the vision of the Barcelona Declaration. “It
is about bringing peoples together through regional cooperation,
partnership and dialogue” (Euromesco report).
Let us move
from a “lose-lose” situation to one of “win-win” from
which we can all benefit.
The present
document showcases Israel’s vision for the future of
the Barcelona process. It is a concrete vision that can be
implemented immediately. It is a vision that can be translated
into concrete action whose results are measurable within a
few years or less as long as we maintain a number of conditions:
In the next
pages we will present a number of ideas and initiatives that
are true to the spirit
described above. These are
ideas which Israel would like
to continue and develop together with other countries who will find them
interesting, with a view to the future of the Euro-Mediterranean
partnership.
Promoting
Gender Equality and Women’s Empowerment
The economic
crises down the years have seriously affected governments’ ability
to assist the vulnerable sectors in grassroots communities
(children, youth, elderly, handicapped and especially women).
The aim of
the proposed project is to contribute to poverty reduction
through socio-economic development programs, by empowering
women and promoting gender equality through an inclusive approach.
The idea
is to implement, within five years, a comprehensive human resources
development program with emphasis on gender in selected countries
in the Mediterranean basin and Middle East.
Professionals,
who have trained in Israel and in their own settings in such
regions, will have acquired the necessary skills and capacity
to manage “community driven” development programs
and thereby enhance the material resources and human capital
of their target population.
With regard
to our long experience in this field, we propose:
To institute
gender mainstreaming through ‘tailormade’ training
programs - workshops and seminars on topics such as: women’s
leadership, participation of women in the labor market, creation
of businesses by women, and support systems for women entrepreneurs.
Empowerment
Through Networking
By building
working links with the Women’s
Mediterranean Forum, MCTC/MASHAV has been able to develop
networks and programs for the empowerment of women
in the Mediterranean basin. It is suggested that the next congress of that
Forum be held in Israel (2007), within the framework of the Euro-Mediterranean
Partnership.
Emergency
and Trauma System
A disaster
is defined as “a catastrophic event which, relative to
the manpower and resources available, overwhelms a healthcare
facility and usually occurs in a short period of time.” Year
after year thousands of people around the world die from natural
disasters, and millions more are injured. Apart from the human
suffering, the financial damages incurred by natural catastrophes
are estimated at billions of dollars annually.
Governments
and relevant organizations need to learn to operate and respond
quickly and efficiently to these disasters. Over the years,
Israel has had to learn to deal with disasters and has built
up a professional response to urgent medical demands. Therefore,
Israel proposes programs and workshops dealing specifically
in emergency medicine and trauma.
Developing
and Organizing a Trauma System
The program
of studies will include: comprehending the continuity of treatment
of trauma
patients in a trauma system, studying the structures involved
in
the various phases of treatment, and developing a specific model of a trauma
system suitable to the participants’ countries of origin.
International
Training Course for Nurses in Emergency Room Nursing and Trauma
Care
This course offers nurses continuing education in emergency room nursing
and multi-trauma injuries. The course will include, among other topics: exposure
to new methods and approaches, medical and nursing techniques in the treatment
of patients, triage principles, nursing intervention and treatment, and principles
of initial first aid in emergency situations and in life-saving skills.
Counter-Terrorism
Research Center (CTRC)
The goal
of the CTRC will be to address the importance of counterterrorism
and to offer an opportunity for better understanding the terrorism
phenomena by encouraging joint research projects on this crucial
issue.
The CTRC
will initiate seminars, workshops and conferences, and help
to bring together national research centers, scholars and students
from the region, while contributing to their interaction and
enabling them to share experiences and knowledge.
The first
stage for creating the CTRC will be to set up a Counter-Terrorism
Research Fund (CTRF) that will dedicate itself to the establishing
of the center and will offer scholarships for researchers to
advance joint projects on the topic of counterterrorism.
Cooperation
in the Field of Technological Innovation
An enhanced
cooperation program is proposed in the field of technological
innovation, a field of great importance for the prosperity
of all the countries in the Mediterranean region.
In this regard,
based on Israel’s extensive experience in the development
of “technological incubators”, the suggestion is
to have an exchange program aimed at assisting the setting
up of similar incubators in other countries of the partnership.
This can be achieved through meetings of policymakers, seminars
and educational and vocational activities.
In these
activities, special emphasis should be given to the younger
generation.
What is a
Technological Incubator?
A technological
incubator is an organization established to provide a supportive
and protective environment for individual inventors and entrepreneurs,
so that technological innovations can be developed into business
ventures.
It provides
a framework and support for nascent companies to develop their
innovative technological ideas and form new business ventures
that can attract private investors.
The program
is opened to private investors so that they can become owners
of the incubators and invest in the nascent companies at an
earlier stage, thus enabling a greater return on their investment.
The main
objective of the government in supporting such a program is
to help entrepreneurs during the seed stage of a project by
assuming the role of a private investor in this very risky
stage of business development.
Cooperation
in the Field of Health Systems Management
In the western
world the last ten years have been characterized by a clear
tendency of using an economic approach in the process of decision-making
in the public health system.
In Israel,
since the implementation in 1995 of the Public Health Law,
much experience and knowledge has been accumulated in the field
of health systems management, in the domain of credible available
data as well as parameters of efficiency and management of
complex health systems.
The proposal
is to develop cooperation in the field of health systems management,
a domain of great importance for the welfare of the population
in all the countries of the Mediterranean region.
The idea
is to share the Israeli experience in confronting the issue
of how to use the limited resources which exist for financing
health expenses versus the needs that are ever increasing due
to different factors that include, among many, the aging of
the population, the decrease in infant mortality, expensive
technological developments, and preventive medicine.
Practically,
the proposal is to organize a seminar which will deal with
such issues as: establishment of unified and comparable data
systems for all the public hospitals, efficient use of the
public health system, multi-year planning of the national health
system, etc.
This proposal
was presented for the first time at the Euro-Med Forum on
Health, held in Barcelona on November 14-15.
The
Fight Against Desertification in the Middle East
In order
to stop the damage caused to the soil as well as rehabilitate
the fertility of dryland regions in the Middle East, it is
recommended to establish mechanisms of regional cooperation
in technology, research and training in the fields of grazing,
afforestation, use of marginal waters, and preservation of
propagating material.
Israel can
provide the researchers and the research infrastructures,
assist in training, cooperate in sustainable development projects
of dryland regions, and transfer knowledge via MASHAV. It
is
also suggested that a research fund be established for applicable
research in “sustainable development of dryland regions
in the Middle East” where experts from countries in
the region can compete.
Mediterranean
Musical Dialogue - Musical Project
The Mediterranean
is not only a geographical and historical area, but also an
imaginary cultural space comprising a diversity of identities
and cultures. The dialogue between these different cultures
has created a unique texture that may be called the Mediterranean
Culture.
Because of
its abstract nature, music serves as an ideal tool for such
dialogue.
Each musical
tradition around the Mediterranean has its own unique identity.
Yet they share many common elements.
The proposal
is to organize in Israel or in another neighboring country
a four-day dialogue with the participation of musicians (instrumentalists,
vocalists and composers) from all Mediterranean countries.
The dialogue, conducted as a series of interrelated workshops,
would aim to create an exchange of ideas among musicians who
create in a “Mediterranean” spirit, i.e. by combining
elements from their different musical cultures while at the
same time learning the principles of their venerable traditions.
Mediterranean
Literary Meetings & Workshops
The annual
event that is proposed will constitute a platform for active
encounters introducing authors, translators, publishers and
media experts from Mediterranean countries to their European
counterparts.
Workshops
will explore the influence of the Mediterranean landscape,
atmosphere, culture, history and languages on the various literatures.
Translation
workshops will deal with specific factors which affect reciprocal
translation between Mediterranean languages such as cultural
backgrounds, linguistic sources, ancient scripts and cultures,
translation policies, and bibliographic data exchange.
Further discussions
may deal with the role of the writer in the respective countries.
The proposed
encounter will further include readings of poetry and prose
by leading authors who will make use of translations, which
are either already published or are done in the workshops.
It is proposed
that the event be repeated on an annual basis, each time in
a different participating country, in order to create an ongoing
literary platform for discussing Mediterranean literatures.
Cinema -
Regional Projects
Between the
years 2001-2003, 13 Israeli projects (8 documentaries and 5
fictional films) received full support from MEDEA, amounting
to a total of 294,000 EUR, thus providing an excellent and
rare opportunity to establish relations with fellow filmmakers
from Europe and the Mediterranean.
Israel would
like to continue co-operation with European and Mediterranean
partners and thus proposes the following projects:
Immigrants
Around the Sea
A workshop
targeted for documentary filmmakers who are working on their
first films, and who were not born in the country in which
they live and create. The workshop will look into the human
and social experience of immigration, cultural identity, and
other themes.
Each participating
country will produce its own films and will receive films made
by the other participants all of which will be broadcasted
on national television networks.
A Mediterranean
Kids Film Festival
A festival
aimed at encouraging the dialogue between the younger generations
in the Mediterranean through filmmaking.
Children
from the participating countries will be invited to tell their
own story using the cinema as their storyboard. The young filmmakers
will be invited to present their films and to meet fellow directors.
Education
for Tolerance
Human history
is rife with examples of man’s inhumanity to man. The
attempt to learn from the past is no guarantee that similar
atrocities will not be committed in the future. We must engage
in a daily battle to eradicate racism, discrimination and incitement.
Every state
is obligated to teach its citizens, especially the children,
tolerance and respect for others. The main way to accomplish
this is through the school system. In today’s world,
the media plays an increasingly central role in shaping society,
for good and for bad. We must confront the possibilities as
well as the threats that our many-faceted, “online” world
presents.
The seminar
that is proposed will take place at an institution that deals
with these issues every day of the year - Yad Vashem, The Holocaust
Martyrs’ and Heroes’ Remembrance Authority. Alternatively,
the seminar could be held in another location, aided by or
under the professional guidance of Yad Vashem.
The seminar
is intended for senior educators and journalists from Europe
and the Mediterranean.
The two or
three-day seminar will consist of three sessions: